The Dangers of Using a Non-CodeMark Certified SIP System in New Zealand: What You Need to Know

When it comes to building a home or commercial structure, the materials you choose play a pivotal role in ensuring safety, durability, and efficiency. Structural Insulated Panels (SIPs) have gained popularity in New Zealand for their superior insulation properties, energy efficiency, and quick installation. However, not all SIP systems are created equal, and opting for a non-CodeMark certified SIP system can pose significant risks. Let's explore the dangers associated with using non-CodeMark certified SIP systems and the potential consequences for homeowners and builders.

1. Compromised Structural Integrity

Certified SIP systems undergo rigorous testing and quality control to ensure they meet industry standards for strength and durability. Non-CodeMark certified SIPs may not have been subjected to these stringent tests, which can result in panels that are structurally unsound. Over time, this can lead to serious issues such as warping, bowing, or even failure under load, compromising the safety of the building and its occupants.

2. Non-Compliance with Building Codes

New Zealand's building codes and regulations are designed to ensure that structures are safe, healthy, and durable. CodeMark certification is the highest level of assurance, providing an unchallengeable proof of compliance with the Building Code. This certification is legally required to be accepted by Building Consent Authorities (BCAs) without the need for further evidence. In contrast, non-CodeMark certified SIPs, even those with a BRANZ Appraisal, might still face scrutiny and potential rejection by BCAs, leading to costly delays and modifications​ (Building Govt)​​ (Branz)​.

3. Increased Fire Risk

Fire safety is a critical consideration in building design. CodeMark certified SIP systems are tested for fire resistance and comply with local fire safety regulations. Non-CodeMark certified SIPs may lack the necessary fire-resistant properties, increasing the risk of rapid fire spread and putting lives and property at greater risk.

4. Poor Thermal Performance

One of the primary benefits of SIPs is their excellent thermal performance, which contributes to energy efficiency and reduced heating and cooling costs. CodeMark certified SIP systems are designed and tested to provide optimal insulation. In contrast, non-CodeMark certified SIPs may not deliver the same level of thermal performance, leading to higher energy bills and a less comfortable living environment.

5. Warranty and Insurance Issues

CodeMark certified SIP systems typically come with warranties that offer peace of mind and protection against defects and failures. Non-CodeMark certified SIPs may not come with such guarantees, leaving homeowners without recourse in the event of a problem. Additionally, insurance companies may refuse to cover buildings constructed with uncertified materials, complicating claims and potentially leading to significant out-of-pocket expenses.

6. Environmental and Health Concerns

CodeMark certified SIP systems are often manufactured using environmentally friendly processes and materials, ensuring low emissions and a healthier indoor environment. Non-CodeMark certified SIPs may be produced using substandard or hazardous materials, posing potential health risks to occupants and contributing to environmental degradation.

7. Resale Value and Marketability

A home or commercial building constructed with CodeMark certified SIPs is likely to have a higher resale value and be more attractive to potential buyers. In contrast, structures built with non-CodeMark certified SIPs may suffer from reduced marketability and lower property values due to the perceived and actual risks associated with uncertified materials.

8. Financial Implications of Failure

The financial implications of using non-CodeMark certified SIP systems can be enormous. If a non-CodeMark SIP system fails, the costs to remediate the structural elements of a building can be massive. These costs may include:

  • Inspection and Assessment Costs: Determining the extent of the damage and identifying the necessary repairs.
  • Material and Labor Costs: Replacing the non-CodeMark SIPs with certified ones, which may involve significant material and labor expenses.
  • Legal Costs: If the failure leads to disputes with contractors, insurers, or regulatory bodies, legal fees can quickly escalate.
  • Loss of Use: During the remediation process, the building may be uninhabitable or unusable, leading to loss of rental income or business operations.
  • Increased Insurance Premiums: Future insurance premiums may increase due to the perceived risk associated with uncertified materials.

These financial burdens can be overwhelming and far outweigh the initial cost savings of opting for non-CodeMark certified SIPs​ (Building Govt)​​ (Building Govt)​.

9. Risks of Importing Non-CodeMark Certified Products

Opting to import SIP products from overseas, particularly from suppliers without local presence or certification, introduces additional risks:

  • Lack of Local Support: Imported non-CodeMark certified SIPs may not come with the same level of local support and service that certified, locally manufactured products offer. This can lead to difficulties in addressing issues, delays in repairs, and a lack of accountability.
  • Quality Assurance: Overseas suppliers may not adhere to the same stringent quality control measures as local manufacturers. This can result in inconsistent product quality and performance.
  • Long-Term Reliability: Without a local company standing behind the product, homeowners and builders have little recourse in the event of defects or failures. This lack of local backing can lead to prolonged disputes and unresolved issues.

CodeMark Certification vs BRANZ Appraisal: What’s the Difference?

Understanding the difference between CodeMark certification and a BRANZ Appraisal is crucial for making informed decisions about building products.

CodeMark Certification

  • Unchallengeable Compliance: CodeMark is the highest level of product assurance. It provides legal status equivalent to that of an Acceptable Solution or Verification Method. Building Consent Authorities (BCAs) must accept a CodeMark product certificate as evidence of compliance with the Building Code without requiring further evidence​ (Building Govt)​​ (Building Govt)​.
  • Stringent Testing: Products with CodeMark certification undergo comprehensive testing and evaluation, ensuring they meet all relevant standards and performance criteria.
  • Market Advantage: CodeMark certification offers a marketing advantage as it signifies that the product meets stringent quality and performance standards, providing confidence to builders and homeowners​ (Building Govt)​.

BRANZ Appraisal

  • Independent Evaluation: A BRANZ Appraisal is an in-depth evaluation of a building product or system by BRANZ, a trusted independent organization. It assesses whether the product is fit for purpose and meets Building Code performance requirements​ (Branz)​.
  • Acceptance by Authorities: While widely accepted by approving authorities in New Zealand, a BRANZ Appraisal may not provide the same level of unchallengeable compliance as CodeMark certification. BCAs may still request additional evidence or documentation.
  • Market Acceptance: A BRANZ Appraisal facilitates faster acceptance in the marketplace and can be a valuable marketing tool, though it does not carry the same weight as CodeMark certification in terms of compliance assurance​ (Branz)​.

Ensuring Peace of Mind with CodeMark Certified SIP Systems

Choosing a CodeMark certified SIP system offers numerous benefits and ensures compliance with New Zealand's stringent building standards. At Formance, we pride ourselves on providing high-quality, certified SIP systems that deliver exceptional performance, safety, and peace of mind.

Our SIPs are manufactured locally, undergo rigorous testing, and come with a comprehensive 20-year warranty. By choosing Formance, you are making a commitment to quality, safety, and sustainability.

In closing…

Building with non-CodeMark certified SIP systems can lead to significant risks and unforeseen consequences. From compromised structural integrity to legal and financial repercussions, the dangers are too great to ignore. Always choose CodeMark certified SIP systems from reputable suppliers to ensure your building project is safe, compliant, and built to last.

For more information about certified SIP systems and how Formance can help with your next building project, please visit our website or contact our team of experts.

For more information about CodeMark check out these links: 

https://www.formance.co.nz/technical/design/codemark-certified-formance-system-2/

https://www.building.govt.nz/building-code-compliance/product-assurance-and-certification-schemes/codemark/about-codemark